All Reviews for Mark T. Wiltberger Cellars
Based on 17 reviews
Fantastic Rieslings!

I have had hit or miss experiences with rieslings in the US and New York State in the past and therefore have steered away from rieslings. Mark's two rieslings - Trilium and Wanderlust - have changed my mind. They are as good or better than some of the fine rieslings I have had in Alsace or Germany. I served both at a New Year's Eve dinner and they were the hit of the night. Right out of the gate, I believe he is a fantastic addition to our region's winemaking and I look forward to whatever Mark produces in the future.

Enjoyed great wines

Pleasantly surprised how easy it was to receive our first four wines. This is the first time we ordered wines to be shipped through the mail. Wanderlust is now my favorite Riesling. I enjoy rieslings that are somewhere in the semi-sweet/semi-dry range. To my taste Wanderlust is a perfect combination of sweetness and an overall clean taste. I would not consider myself a wine expert, but I have enjoyed a number of finger lakes rieslings as well as rieslings from other areas. Wanderlust would now be my first choice over all others. I also enjoyed the Convivial.

Sampler Four-Pack
Excellent quality, Excellent value

My wife and I thought the wine selection was excellent. We enjoyed them all, but the Riesling was definitely our favorite. Looking forward to purchasing more in the near future.

Outstanding riesling

We enjoy the wine very much. The Trillium riesling is our favorite. It's really excellent. Wanderlust is a touch sweeter, but very nicely balanced. The Convivial Gruner is a little unusual for the variety, floral. The Open Door Chardonnay is a nice, easy sipper.

Delicious white wines!

Great stuff! Keep up the good work Mark!


The wine is amazing. And I’m not just saying that because you are my nephew. Friends enjoyed it too. Love the label design and the unique names also.

Sampler Four-Pack
Loved it!

Had a dinner party over the winter holidays and the wine was a perfect fit. Light, fresh and bright... my only wish was that I was drinking during summer. I'll just have to order another round.

Sampler Six-Pack

Great again Mark .I prefer the Open Door and Wanderlust. Hopefully on the future I can just order those 2.

Hi Joan, I can customize the selection for you to some degree. However in future years the selection of wines will vary depending on what I produce that vintage. Mark
Strong Right Out of the Gate

Mark Wiltberger is far from a novice vintner. For decades he has patiently learned his trade and so his first offerings deliver at a far higher quality than other new wineries, perhaps any other. We plan to visit the winery this summer and look forward to tasting more wines throughout the year. About half of our first shipment went to friends as gifts, so we may need to reorder soon.

Tasteful new winery

The first vintage from Mark T. Wiltberger winery on Keuka Lake is everything one could ask for in white wines - beautiful bouquet and smooth flavors with a satisfying finish. If you like Chardonnay, Riesling, or Gruner Veltliner these wines are for you. Thumbs up to Mark.

Proud to be a winery founder.

All of Mark's wines are delightful. His hard work and determination to produce great wine has paid off. Will continue to share Mark's wonderful wine in Colorado. Congratulations on launching your new winery.

Love that you named the wines and then put the grape on the bottom. Your wines are really good.

Keep up the good work. We are all rooting for you. I recommend you to a lot of friends.

Sampler Twelve-Pack

Enjoyed it. Very smooth. Good flavor.
Bill sullivan

Holiday Sampler Six-Pack
Very Impressed!

Excellent wine and service. Count me as a dedicated new customer!

Sampler Four-Pack
Great wine!

I recently purchased the sampler four pack. Loved it. Outstanding wine. Quick, easy and convenient delivery. Highly recommended!

Riesling 2014 "Trillium"

This is a layered, complex wine. Delightful. It's color is very light gold. I taste lemon with honey, agave, but not seeet. Trillium is thrilling.

Gruner Veltliner "Convivial"

This elegant full bodied wine is an excellent match for oysters.